Topper Copies

I.d) Matrilineal Puzzle

Sania Seervi, AIR 450, 2025

Descent as per Murdock is allocation of individual to consanguineal kinsmen. Matrilineal descent refers to allocation to line of mother.

Here property is inherited as follows:

[a boxed kinship/descent diagram using triangles and circles, some shaded, with a curved line labelled "line of descent"]

However, such societies are not matriarchal, which means authority truly is held by an associated male member.

- When this male is own brother -> matrilineal societies are built around brother-sister relation - Here, brother faces the dilemma over residence due to his role conflict of natural love for biological son v/s dual responsibility towards sister's son

Thus either the brother resides at his sister's house, or at his own -> Visiting husband system, or his wife's house -> permanent husband system.

Case: Nayars - Tharavad - Kathleen Gough

[a composite of three kinship/residence diagrams using triangles and circles connected by marriage and descent lines, with arrows labelled "visiting husband" and "visiting at wife"; the left and middle groups are labelled "residence group 2" and the right group is labelled "residence group 1"]

This creates tensions for the male members due to conflict, as he is associated with his biological son before puberty and sister's son after puberty. However this conflict is avoided in case of Garo, Khasi matrilineal societies as authority is exercised by husband.

Thus, this dilemma and toxic situation of matrilineal puzzle has its roots in patriarchal setup, despite matrilineality.