Topper Copies

7.(c) Briefly explain the idea of Culture Circle in German school of Diffusionism. Also highlight the contribution made by prominent scholars of this school. (20 marks)

Eshani Anand, AIR 79, 2023

Diffusionism school of thought arose in opposition to evolutionist who believed in psychic unity of mankind and did not accounted for diffusion.

German school also called Migrationists believed in theory "Culture traits" or "centre of innovation" where all cultural traits dispersed, diffused due to migration and culture contact.

Concept of Culture Circle [a world map marking four culture circles (Kulturkreise), cross-hatched, with arrows showing diffusion by migration, captioned "Kulturkreis and Diffusion"]

Contribution by Major Scholars 1) Ratzel in "Anthropology and Geography" stated that geography limits a cultural expansion. He gave concept of geography and culture relation. He studied forms of bow and arrow in Indonesia and West Africa and concluded that "forms" of material remain same.

2) Frobenius: student of Ratzel elaborated on study. Compared bow arrow, musical instruments of Indonesia. He gave the following theory: 1. Man is uninventive and trait gets borrowed 2. There is no psychic unity of mankind 3. Geography can limit adoption of traits

3) Schmidt adopted "historic" perspective. He gave 4 culture circles.

[four concentric culture circles labelled Primitive (hunting/gathering, Bushmen), 1° Horticultural, 2° Pastoral and 2° Agricultural]

He said 4 such circles exist in the world and historically have developed and diffused culture to various areas.

4) Graebner study in Melanesia. Applying this theory he studied historic perspective of the diffusion.

[five concentric circles labelled Tasmanian culture, bow and arrow culture, totemic culture, Dramanian culture, and present melanesian culture]

He said that from various culture circles these traits had diffused and caused "new methods" of adoption of culture.

The Idea of Migrations 1. Trade and migration were carriers of traits 2. Culture did not evolve individually alone but underwent some local adaptive

Criticisms of School of Thought 1. It was difficult to formulate culture circles 2. Too much dependence on 'museum' methodology 3. Why diffusion occurred, the reason and mechanism was not elaborated

Franz Boas, Clark Wissler, Kroeber gave concept of "culture area" to further study diffusion.

In many ways theory gave impetus to "multilinear Evolution of Man".