Q7. (a) The technological system is both primary and basic in importance as all human life and culture rest and depend upon it". Elaborate the statement in keeping in mind Leslie White's theory of cultural evolution. (15 marks)
Eshani Anand, AIR 79, 2023
Leslie White's Theory of Cultural Evolution is called "technological determinism". He believed that technology was the basic system over which social system and ideology depended on.
Cardinal Points of Theory of Cultural Evolution (Technology as primary and basic) 1. Believed in "Culturology": one general law can explain all cultures. He was a Neo-Evolutionist 2. Believed in universal cultural evolution 3. Stated that cultural materialism with energy per capita should be the theorising of culture
The Three Systems of Culture
Technology: He said helps us raise energy used per capita per year. This leads to efficiency in culture.
Typology of Culture as per Technology can System:
| Stage | Technology | |---|---| | Paleolithic | Used muscle as technology (hunting/gathering) | | Neolithic | Use of plants and animals as technology | | Iron Age | Use of oil, fuel etc | | Energy Revolution | Use of nuclear energy |
Thus he gave the formula: C = T x E is cultural evolution (C) is the product of technology and efficiency and it accumulates.
Achievements and Tenets of Theory 1. Gave an empirical and cross cultural reasoning to evolutionists (arm chair and ethnocentric) 2. Inspired Marshall Sahlins and Elman Service to formulate general theories of parallelism and Convergence of culture based on technological system as a base
Criticism 1. Julian Steward said that general laws of culture are not sound. Each geography and region needs to be studied as multilinear evolution 2. He gave concept of culture ecology to counter the theory 3. Moreover, it failed to explain why some cultures advance in technology and some degenerate 4. Roy Rappaport said other facets of culture, religion etc, ignored. But theory gave etic, objective and empirical perspective to evolution