i.c) How does Postmodernism challenge traditional notions of objectivity and truth in anthropological research? (15 marks)
Eshani Anand, AIR 79, 2023
"Postmodernism" was coined by Arnold Toynbee to denote a new way of thinking and attacking notion of science, reason and objectivity. M. Spiro says "objectivity is an illusion and truth has multiple voices."
Kuzner says major tenet of Postmodernism is that "Culture is inferior" as it is riddled with western, colonial connotations.
Challenges from Postmodernism 1) Reflexivity: Malinowski's writings reflected racist and patriarchal bias (said Ann Weiner). Thus this is the "conscious self introspection" a researcher must do in research.
Thus reflexivity takes into account researchers, gender, age, race etc.
Victor Crapanzano in "Hermes Dilemma and Hamlet Desire" says the researcher must maintain a log of self awareness.
Postmodernism Questions: the ideals of culture => real behaviour of culture.
2) Meta Narrative: Lyotard says that one underlying definition of phenomenon is not possible. Due to various local contexts and relativism, the ultimate absolute truth cannot be found.
3) Polyvocality: Post modernism says multiple truths are possible and thus objectivity and truth cannot be got.
4) Relation of Power and Knowledge: Foucault said "Power is 100 microprocess in research" and thus true objectivity cannot be got.
5) Deconstruction and Post structuralism: Derrida in "Of Grammatology" said language can never be totally replicated through structural studies. He said texts must be deconstructed.
Rosneau's method:
6) Against historical approach: They state that history cannot be objective.
Criticism of Postmodernism Roy Bhaskar says postmodernism is against science but is taking us far from near truth too. It is focusing too much on power.