b) What were the main ideas proposed by Tylor in his influential work "Primitive Culture"? (15 marks)
Eshani Anand, AIR 79, 2023
E.B Tylor called "Father of Anthropology".
In his seminal work "Primitive Culture" defined "Culture" as that complex whole of knowledge, art, belief, ideas, material that man acquires by being part of society.
1) Evolution of Culture: He applied positivistic approaches and believed that culture evolved like a biological organism.
Influences: He stated that similar to Herbert Spencer's theory and Darwin's theory of evolution culture evolved.
(i.) Culture evolved from simple to complex, homogenous to heterogeneous and from uniform to nonuniform forms.
1.2) He gave concept of "Psychic Unity of Mankind". He said there is "general likeness that all humans share".
1.3) Concept of "Cultural Parallels". He said cultures from Africa to South East Asia were in some time period or another. Thus drawing parallels, we know that all share psychic unity.
1.4) Cultural Survivals: He said remnants of a culture remains and this shows cultural evolution. Eg he showed example of coat tail and button behind jackets. He said clay pots are not in use but are used for shows.
1.5) Culture evolved in stages:
As we move left: decreasing "primitiveness" (denogatory), progress increases.
2) Religion in Primitive Culture He said Animism is the most basic primitive culture. It is the belief in a general dominating soul and general supernatural.
He said evolution:
Genesis of animism: He said it was to explain the phenomenon of death, dreams and other unexplainable scenarios. He called them irrational and incorrect.
3) Methods: He used hand written notes, magazines, secondary information to formulate the same.
Criticism Against Primitive Culture 1. Diffusionists: lack of attention to diffusion and concerned psychic unity of man 2. Franz Boas & Mead: speculative, pseudo and conjectural, no attention to necessity 3. Neoevolutionists: lack of empirical basis
Despite this Tylor inspired many anthropologists and was one of first to establish it as a discipline.