Q6. "In practice, we find that myth, magic, and religion are a direct response to the vital needs, interests, and emotions of mankind. They deal with the fundamental problems of existence." How did Malinowski view the functions of myth, magic, and religion in addressing the fundamental needs and concerns of human societies? (20 marks)
Eshani Anand, AIR 79, 2023
Malinowski in Coral Gardens and Their Magic said "Myths, Magic and religion" is in fact that hope cannot fail.
Malinowski's View on Function of Myth, Magic, Religion Malinowski's functionalism is called "Bio cultural" or "psychological functionalism".
He said, in "Every civilization, every belief, idea, value, material has a function/task and this indispensable fact integrates it to be entire functioning whole of culture" [The Scientific Theory of Culture].
i) Magic, myths, religion satisfy needs of an individual (The Theory of Needs)
Case Study of Kula Trade The Trobrianders take Kula (ceremonial exchange) and perform that they do rituals for canoe and do expressions art and magic. The imitative magic is done for safe journey. The directing trade is based on myth and is enforced by belief.
| Rituals | Trade | Tools | |---|---|---| | Myth | Ceremonial exchange | Adaptation | | Religion | Religion, exchange | Allow for social order | | Colouring, murals | | |
Thus in integration of all these aids needs, emotional solutions. In difficult unpredictable times, the tribes fall back on them.
Myth In Coral Gardens & the magic he cited the myth:
Thus functioning myth: 1. Social order and hierarchy 2. Territorial and dispute resolution 3. Identity of individual
Magic and Religion Malinowski said "When all technical fails, the tribe turns to magic and religion. They do not differentiate between the two and address vital desires of society."
Theory of Needs Malinowski said that at 3 levels the culture fulfils needs:
Primitive Vital influences: these are basic needs of man:
| Need | Cultural response | |---|---| | Metabolism | Commissariat | | Movement | Activities | | Growth | Training | | Reproduction | Kinship | | Hygiene | Health | | Comfort | Shelter | | Safety | Protection |
Durkheim Imperative 2° Needs: He said to fulfil primary needs certain 2° needs are got:
| Imperative | Institution | |---|---| | Cultural apparatus | Economy | | Sanction | Socialisation | | Power | Authority | | Human Behaviour | Education |
At the level after this, myth, magic and religion fulfil the needs of a culture.
Criticism of Malinowski 1. Did not count dysfunctional role of culture. Evans Pritchard said that dances and rites in African tribes create conflict 2. Used tautological, normative and ahistorical approach
However relevance of this theory can explain rise in religiosity in atheist China as job crisis and cost of living rises among youth.