Define "cultural relativity" in its weak, intermediate, and strong forms. Why is understanding cultural relativity important in the objective study of cultures throughout the world?
Nidhi Pai
The concept of Cultural Relativity was given by Franz Boas.
- Cultural Relativity believes in an objective study of Culture. According to Classical Relativism, societies or cultures must be studied in relation to its own history and environment and not based on the standard of one's own culture. - It is an anti-thesis to Ethnocentrism (CR).
Cultural Relativity in its weak, intermediate and strong forms
- CR in its weak form - Though there is a sense of need felt to objectively study cultures, yet the biases of our own cultures might stop us from fully acknowledging other cultures. (Ex) Though, as Hindus, we might believe that cow is holy, there is a sense of repulsion when we see someone consuming beef on part of us. - CR in Intermediate form -> the most desirable one to study cultures objectively. - One may choose to keep one's personal biases or judgements away and study cultures. - Follow the Emic view of study of cultures. - (Ex) Malinowski's study of Trobriand Islanders. Studied the systems of kula system, wani system etc without letting his knowledge of formal economics study influence his observations. - CR in strong form - Though Cultural Relativism must be followed, it is important that one does not blind himself as to what is right or wrong. (Ex) - 1. The cultural practice of Sati cannot be supported under the guide of Cultural Relativism. 2. Female Genital Mutilation among some communities.
Why is Cultural Relativity Important to study Cultures?
1. In order to understand cultures from the observer's point of view (Emic approach). 2. To avoid any kind of Ethnocentrism. 3. To provide objective and unbiased ethnographies and researches. 4. To ensure any kind of racism or discrimination of people involved in a study is avoided. 5. To provide a holistic study of cultures. 6. To provide for future comparisons and study of cultures. 7. To avoid any kind of political, economic or social bias. 8. To ensure inclusivity in one's studies.
Ex - Tribal India is often known for its exotic living styles and the existence of pre-marital sexual relations. This reflects Ethnocentrism.
Cultural Relativity in studies will help people appreciate the beauty, charm and uniqueness of different cultures across the world.