(c) Briefly explain theories of Origin of Languages. (15 marks)
Eshani Anand, AIR 79, 2023
Edward Sapir stated that language is a human and non deliberate way of communicating ideas, desires and patterns in voluntary manner.
Biological Theories 1. Laryngeal Descent: It states that as we became bipedal the hyoid bone descended and created space for the larynx to grow. This allowed sounds.
[a simple neck-anatomy drawing labelled larynx, hyoid bone and neck anatomy]
2. Noam Chomsky's Universal Grammar: He says we all have a "Linguistic Acquisition Device" (LAD) that has a natural propensity to learn language. 3. Svante Paabo and fox P2: He stated that fox P2 mutation is found in echolocation mammals. This mutation may have allowed sounds.
Criticism of Biological Theories: do not explain diversity of languages, discount role of culture.
Cultural Theories 1. Divine Theory: Every culture has a myth that it's gods created language. Yahweh, god in Central Asia created tongue to confuse the people (Judaism) 2. Imitation Theories, we imitated:
3. Needs Theory: 1. 40 Me ho: Theory that naturalistic and conventional behaviour is required, ritualistic and coherent shorting 2. Theory of Mind/lying Theory: EM Structuralist said that to create lies (once we understood scenario) we needed language 3. Warning Hypothesis: related to gesture call, there need to call out in emergency, in dark, over walls led to language 4. Roy Rappaport says a combination of all led to language
Conclusion 1. Language is a part of culture and thus may have a bio-cultural origin as seen in studies of primatology, child development 2. Linguistic Determinism states that language is beginning of all thought
Recently, a new "Putting the baby down" theory states that as babies could not cling to fur of mother every time it was put down, women created language.