(b) Cultural practices and beliefs can be understood as adaptive responses to environmental and economic constraints. Comment. (15 marks)
Eshani Anand, AIR 79, 2023
Culture is adaptive and its responses are based on environmental and economic constraints. It can be elaborated by: 1. Neoevolutionism 2. Historical Particularism & Diffusion 3. Functionalism 4. Cultural Materialism
1) Neoevolutionism Julian Steward said that culture's evolution is in a biocultural manner. Each area has its own way of using the environmental mechanism.
Culture ecology:
He said: 1. Culture interacts with environmental constraints 2. The technology and subsistence is based on these factors 3. These decide the beliefs etc
(b2) Leslie White, technological determinism: Technology system is based on energy harnessed from the environment. This in turn impacts ideology, practices, beliefs.
2) Cultural Materialism Marvin Harris in "The Rise of Anthropological Thought" gave concept of "infrastructural determinism". The culture is sustained if infrastructure (production and reproduction) is maintained.
In India's sacred cow he said cow provides fuel, fertilizer and nutrients thereby ensuring subsistence and population survival. Thus it aids kinship bonds and becomes sacred (superstructure).
3) Historical Particularism and Diffusion Franz Boas said that 3 factors decide culture development: psychology of people, resources used and environment, along with climate and demography.
Based on this culture area and culture concept of Kroeber were got. Culture areas can depend on environment and economic factors:
[a hand-drawn map of North and South America marking culture areas: Caribou, Great Bison, Corn and Chicha in North America; Amazon, Salmon, Inca and Guanaco in South America]
Thus environment and economy decides the culture.
4) Functionalism Malinowski said Culture is need satisfying and need fulfilling system that propagates as long as environmental & economic needs are fulfilled.
Post modernists criticize that there is no separation of nature and culture.