1.d) Etic vs Emic approach of study
Aniket Ranjan, AIR 48, 2025
Etic approach Etic approach focuses on the external factor. It does not go to the deeper and inner layer of analysis of culture.
| Merits | Demerits | |---|---| | Aims to generalise | It overlooks the deeper layers. | | Gives the Cross cultural analysis factor. | No subjectivity. | | It is universal and permanent idea | excess focus on structure, objectivity | | Based on objectivity and rationality | Here the individual agency is sidelined. |
Example of Etic approach 1. Marvin Harris idea of cultural Materialism is based on etic approach, wherein infrastructure will change the structure and super-structure 2. Classical evolutionist gave the terms like Savagery, Barbarism by being in arm chair.
Emic approach Emic approach focus on the inner meanings and deeper layers.
| Merits | Demerits | |---|---| | Subjectivity | lacks the universality | | Contextual and differentiated meaning | It cannot be generalised. | | Individual agency | Too much subjectivity can lead to data manipulation. | | Based on Mental structures. | |
Example => Geertz - study of the Balinese cock fight; Franz Boas study of Kwakiutl; Malinowski - trobriand
Thus, the etic & emic approach both should be used consciously.