Topper Copies

Q4. (a) Mead's major contribution to anthropological theory was her demonstration of the importance of cultural rather than biological conditioning. Elaborate with relevant examples and case studies. (20 marks)

Eshani Anand, AIR 79, 2023

Margaret Mead said that biology is not destiny. She implied that culture and child rearing practices decide personality and not biology.

Margaret Mead and Contributions 1. Sex and Temperament in 3 Primitive Societies: She studied the Arapesh, Mundugumor (Biwat), Tschambuli (Chambri). These cultures lived in same environment but had different cultures and personalities. 1. Arapesh: They were a cooperative culture that did imitative magic for welfare. Men and women were equals. The children were docile and friendly ("feminine traits") 2. Mundugumor: They had constant conflicts in family. Polygamy created mistrust and conflict in society. Thus children were reared to be aggressive and violent 3. Chambli: Women dominated the culture, they were property holders and had essential socio religious role. Here women dominated the men and men remained weak and docile

This culture conditions child psychology and leads to adult behaviour.

2. Coming up of Adolescence Samoa: She compared adolescence of Samoa children and American. 1. Samoa children were taught to be obedient and mindful of cultural values 2. In adolescence, premarital relationship, such exposure was not proscribed 3. Adolescents remained free of anxiety and forward looking

She contrasted the culture with American adolescence which was full of "storm and stress":

| Samoa | America | |---|---| | No storm and stress | Storm and stress | | Easy transition to sexual maturity | Turbulent transition |

Here differences due to cultural conditioning.

3. "Growing up in New Guinea": She studied Manus tribe where culture decides personality and not biology 4. "Male and Female": In this she said that gendered socialisation in milieu of culture lead to differences in the sexes. She said "Gender is not biology, it is cultural" 5. Use of Visual Anthropology in Balinese study, "Growth of a Culture": Photographic analysis of Balinese. In this she said that while taking photographs, the elders often directed the young ones and showed them poses. Thus cultural influences are important for conditioning.

Thus she showed that culture forms personality and this creates adult choices, human behaviour and worldview.

Contributions of Mead 1. D Freeman said interpretation was anecdotal, and storm was found in Samoans 2. Interpretation of Chambri culture was incomplete as males were absent 3. M. M. Harris criticized Samoan study and said infrastructure determines culture, not just the conditioning

However, her contribution can be used to study sports culture in Tanzania: the rise of female sportspersons and conditioning.