Topper Copies

Comment on the following in about 150 words each: (e) David Schneider idea of symbols

Eshani Anand, AIR 79, 2023

David Schneider belongs to Chicago school of culture and wrote "American Kinship: A Cultural Account".

Idea of Symbols He said symbol is "something that stands for something else". He said culture is "set of symbols with meanings". His ideas are: 1. Symbols and their meanings should be studied to unravel culture of people 2. An emic perspective of an insider view aids better ethnography. "Culture is in mind of culture bearers" 3. He said relation between symbols need to be studied

Difference from Idea of Geertz Geertz studied symbols of daily craft. David Schneider states that such symbols do not give holistic picture.

Difference from Idea of Turner David said even unobservable symbols should be studied. Eg belief system and spirits do not have physical presence but relation of symbols to others can be done.

Study of Kinship He said "kinship is a system of symbols and meanings". Two levels of study in culture:

He associated this to other symbols like political, food, clothing etc.

Criticism Talal Assad says such studies are tough to replicate. They remain descriptive. Post modernists say total emic can never be got.