Topper Copies

Comment on the following in about 150 words each: (c) Reflexivism and Deconstruction in Post-modernism

Eshani Anand, AIR 79, 2023

Reflexivism and Deconstruction are tenets of post modernism. Postmodernism (as philosophy) is challenge to objectivity, science and human reason of the modernist era.

Reflexivism Is the conscious self awareness by an anthropologist checking biases.

Emergence of reflexivity: Malinowski's writings on Trobrianders were found to have racist and patriarchal tones. Anne Weiner pointed out in her restudies.

Geertz stated that the study of culture has to be "inside" and not "outsider looking in".

Autoethnographies: Victor Crapanzano says in "Hermes Dilemma and Hamlet Desire" that auto-ethnographies, that are logs of self awareness, need to be created.

Practicing reflexivity: (i) anthropologist must avoid the idealistic behaviour (ii) must compare with actual behaviour, must dwell biases.

Deconstruction Derrida in "Of Grammatology" says deconstruction of texts is needed: 1. due to metanarratives [cannot give 1 definition] 2. against structural approach [binary oppositions leave out oppressed groups] 3. has power and bias of researcher [white, western, colonial ideas] 4. polyvocality [truth is not absolute]

In this school deconstruction of texts is done.

Stranger and Friend: Hortense Powdermaker: in this book he says that anthropologist is "never full time member" of the group. Thus biases can creep in and reflexivity is needed.

Criticism of Postmodern Thought Foucault says it casts doubt on science and truth itself. M Sahlins said power has too much focus.

However, medical anthropology has benefitted from their tenets for getting an insider perspective.