Culture is unique to human beings. Do you agree? Present arguments in favour and against the statement. (15 marks)
Dwij Goel
Culture as per E.B Tylor's book "The Primitive Culture" is a complete whole of knowledge, art, morals, values, beliefs.
Culture exists nearly in every society, however whether it's unique to humans is debated.
Unique to humans 1. Humans can modify the environment around them, argued Herskovits; it's the man-made part of environment, thus it should be unique to humans. 2. It satisfies the need of individual and society, which helps in maintaining social structure; social structure is part of human society, not animals. - Animals do not have social structure, but survival makes dominance. 3. Aristotle and Spencer talked of man as a social animal: in order to survive, creates interdependence and thus society and culture forms; such thing does not happen in animals. 4. Culture is considered superorganic by Durkheim, Spencer and Kroeber. It has its own set of rules and several institutions to make it; it can thus be considered unique to humans, as it is shared collectively. 5. Kroeber said culture can't exist without society, and such societies are a function of human relation.
Not unique 1. Jane Goodall's study on Chimpanzees shows termite tool hunting is a form of culture that exists. 2. Spain's parliament in 2008 allowed for Human Rights for Great Apes, as they remember decisions, symbols, learn from teaching. 3. Some form of culture exists within animals, ex grooming in monkeys. 4. Unity and collectivism during feeding is observed among wild animals. 5. Language as a form of culture is used, like making voice, swelling of genitals (for mating).
Thus, it can be said though some form of culture exists in other animals also, but complex form of culture, which we call superorganic and superindividual, is unique to humans.