7.b) Culture is unique to human beings. Do you agree? Present arguments in favour and against the statement. (15 marks)
Vidyanshu Shekhar Jha
E.B Tylor defined culture as "complex whole of knowledge, belief, art, customs as other capability acquired by Man as part of society".
Herskovits defined culture as man-made part of environment.
Leslie White in his work "Evolution of Culture (1959)" mentioned 5 characteristics due to which Culture could come only to humans: 1. Erect posture 2. Freely opposable thumb 3. Stereoscopic vision 4. Intelligent brain 5. Creators of symbol & bestow meaning upon them
Michael Tomasello says only humans are capable of pooling their cognitive resources.
Non-Human culture - Jane Goodall (1986) studied chimpanzee at Gombe National Park (Tanzania) - Chimpanzee eat ant & termite by breaking twigs and removing leaves then inserting this into termite nest - This is cultural phenomena as chimps learn this by trial & error. Also at other places anting is done differently - Kawai (1965) -> Japanese monkey potato washing - AI project of Kyoto University -> Chimps able to play computer games and help others learn
Ultimately the culture seen in chimpanzee is rudimentary. But still, it is culture as it is learnt.