Topper Copies

4.b) How do descent theories and alliance theories differ in their approaches to understanding kinship and social organization? Also highlight how does the phenomena of 'same-sex marriage' challenges and reshapes traditional cultural norms and kinship systems. (15 marks)

Vidyanshu Shekhar Jha

Descent and Alliance theories are two ways to understand kinship & social organization.

Descent Theory - By: Structural-Functionalist - Says descent rules determine kinship and social organization - Gave 6 types of descent, including: - Unilineal - Ambilineal - Bi-lineal - Bi-lateral - etc. - Says Unilineal descent is main type of descent determining kinship - Ignores importance of marriage in kinship

Alliance Theory - By Levi Strauss, as a reaction to Descent theories - Says Marriage alliance, between two groups, from generation to generation, gives rise to kinship - Exchange of women between groups lead to creation of alliance, hence strengthening their survival - Hence incest-taboo is critical aspect

Impact of same-sex-marriage 1. It defies traditional definition of marriage ie. Marriage as a union between a man and a woman, by Westermarck 2. Changes nomenclature eg. In Male-Male marriage, both are called "husbands" 3. Acceptance of sperm-donor/egg-donor to raise a family 4. Challenging traditional gender roles

Hence same-sex marriage brings individual choices at front, while also showing society's growing tolerance towards them.