Q.4) (a) What are the various forms of exchange and reciprocity found in different societies, and how do they shape social relationships and power dynamics? (20 marks)
Vidyanshu Shekhar Jha
Karl Polygani has defined exchange as method of patterning trade in goods and services
He gave 3 types of exchange.
Generalised reciprocity - Here there's sharing of produce with kins - There is no expectation of return - No timeline for return - One-way trade - A => B - Lorna Marshall studied Kalahari tribe who share hunted meat with kins
Balanced Reciprocity - There's expectation of return - There is an expected timeline - 2-way trade: A <-> B - eg.
Negative Reciprocity - Goal is to get maximum in return, in exchange for giving minimum or nothing - Includes cheating, forgery, etc - eg. Vedda tribe v/s local blacksmith
Redistribution
Potlach based - Giving away of wealth, to elevate social status - eg. Yam distribution at Trobriand Islanders studied by Malinowski
Administration based - All produce is collected at a centralised authority, from where it is redistributed
Shaping Social Relation & Power Dynamics 1. Generalised reciprocity - Brings kins closer - Fosters trust & cooperation 2. Balanced reciprocity - Strengthens alliance - But failure to meet expectation can dent alliance 3. Negative reciprocity - Leads to conflict, theft, dishonesty 4. Redistribution - Elevates social status - Ensures equitable distribution of output