3.c) How does Polanyi's understanding of the social embeddedness of economic activity challenge traditional conceptions of the economy as a separate sphere of life? (15 marks)
Vidyanshu Shekhar Jha
Karl Polanyi in his work: "the great transformation" has introduced substantivist concept of economy, hence challenging traditional understanding of economy.
Traditional Concept - Led by Schneider, Sailsbury - Says traditional market forces are dominant - Goal is profit maximization - Resources are to be exploited at best
Substantivist Understanding - He was supported by Dalton and Bohanan - Says social forces play more vital role in simple societies - There is generalised and balanced reciprocity - Sahlins: "Money to west is kin to rest" - Social embeddedness: economic activities are influenced by socio-cultural context eg. Potlach as means of wealth redistribution eg. Kogi Indians don't do farming even on fertile land, as they believe ancestor's soul rest there
Hence Polygani's work emphasised role of socio-cultural forces in economic behavior.
However Tim Ingold has criticised his work for ignoring economic aspect. He also says that negative reciprocities exists in all societies.