(b) Discuss the nature of Law and Justice in simple societies citing suitable examples. (15 marks)
Utkarsh Ujjwal
As per Radcliffe Brown, the focus of law and justice in primitive societies is not to punish the accused but maintain the social structure.
Hoebel defined it as a social institution aimed to check deviance of individual behaviour
JUSTICE : the act of adjudicating a conflict to settle the issue
Characteristics of simple societies: - primitive political organization - laws are embedded in kinship - lack of law enforcement agency - Justice aimed at maintaining status quo - chiefs/leaders settle disputes - non monetary economy
types of laws and justice
→ Radcliffe Brown replaced 'laws' with "social sanction" in primitive societies and noted that it can be
NON VIOLENT
1. Avoidance of conflicting parties eg: !Kung Bushmen 2. settlement by chief/leader eg- By Melanesian Bigman 3. Giving feast to all parties 4. Oath and ordeal -> to instill the fear of totemic object eg: Nuer, Munda tribes force accused to touch iron hot rod 5. Negotiation and mutual understanding 6. Other → Jean Briggs studied 'Eskimo song duel' where all parties gather around and the conflicting parties may (agree) for their → Evans Pritchard studied dispute settlement in Nuer societies by leopard skin chief
VIOLENT
(i) Gang warfare : eg: African tribes (ii) Retributive Justice : the Victim is allowed to kill the accused
They, simple societies focus more on quick dispute resolution without disruption of social structure