Compare economic and political systems of the Nuer and Trobrianders.
Harsh Nehara, AIR 74, 2025
Nuer's are a group of primitive people living in South Sudan. They were extensively studied by Evans-Pritchard.
Trobrianders are a fishing-cultivating community living in Trobriand Islands of western Pacific. Their life was illustrated in "The argonauts of the western pacific (1922)" by Bronislaw Malinowski.
Economic Systems Economic systems are set of principles that govern production, ownership, distribution and consumption in a society
(a) Production (i) Nuer's: they are pastoral herders dependent upon cattle for production. (ii) Trobrianders: depended on fishing and marginal cultivation for production.
(b) Ownership (i) Nuers: resources are owned by the lineage in common, there is some personal ownership of articles, clothings, No land ownership. (ii) Trobrianders: individual ownership of boats, nuts, harpoons exist. land cultivated by community as whole.
(c) Distribution (i) Nuers: Generalised reciprocity and balanced reciprocity within lineage. Barter and negative reciprocity with outside. (ii) Trobrianders: Kula exchange a form of balanced reciprocity among Islands
(d) Consumption (i) Nuers: Some storage of hides, animal product consumed immediately (ii) Trobrianders: immediate consumption of fish and some processing for trade
Political System Refers to maintenance of orderly relations among groups of within territory
| Nuers | Trobrianders | |---|---| | (i) A lineage based tribe system. | (i) A chiefdom with a hereditary head | | (ii) Strong territory protection | (ii) limited territory mobility | | (iii) lineage form feuding Groups | (iii) Conflict between Islands prevented by Kula exchange and interdependence | | (iv) Mediation by leopard skin chief to resolve conflict | (iv) Resolution by Chief | | (v) Social control by Oath, ordeal, etc | (v) Social control by withdrawal of reciprocity |
With increased cultural contact, these systems have undergone considerable Change