(d) Matrilineal Puzzle (10 Marks)
Utkarsh Ujjwal
Matrilineal puzzle is a situation wherein a matrilineal society has a potential of conflicts between a women's brother and her in-husband.
[a kinship sketch showing a woman's brother, marked "a member of society", in conflict with her husband, marked "from outside"]
Puzzle : Robin Cox has noted following functions that marriage must perform
(i) Impregnation of women by men (ii) Male control over economic property (iii) Incest taboo (ie exogamy)
In order to fulfil (ii), men have to be brought from outside. But in order to fulfil (i), husbands should abandon economic control, else brothers and husband will be in conflict.
This may lead to → instability in society → collapse of matrilineal order
Many societies have evolved mechanisms to fulfil all 3 conditions
a) Kathleen Gough noted the institution of marriage is loose in Nayars where visiting husbands have no control over women's properties
b) Hilda Dube studied matriliny in Lakshadweep (Islam) tribes and noted that the tribes follow some parts of patrilineal (Islam) and matriliny.
Thus, matrilineal puzzle is solved by societies in different manners. As per structural functionalist, such adaptation is a means to assure social stability.