Topper Copies

The origins and practice of modern anthropology are bound up with the colonial era. Discuss.

Harsh Nehara, AIR 74, 2025

Prof. N.K. Vaid has defined Anthropology as the study of socio-cultural as well as biological evolution of man. (Oriental anthropologist, 2013)

(J.K. Penniman, "100 years of Anthropology")

Influence of colonialism on Anthropology

1. Origins (a) Scholars were initially employed to gather information about natives to govern them better. F. Buchannon (1807) as Ethnographic Surveyor of India. (b) Data and information lead rise of "Armchair" anthropology, theorising about evolution and origins of various cultures. (c) The spatial differences were interpreted as temporal ones by scholars like Tylor, Morgan, etc eg Savagery → Barbarism → Civilization (d) Racial studies conducted led to Justification of Colonialism and white mans burden eg a branching classification from "lineaus" into "Homo americanus", "H. Africanus", "H. monstrosus"

2. Practices (a) Questionnaires that were divorced from natives perspectives were floated, leading to incomplete understanding eg Morgan's questions about kin terms. (b) Initial fieldworks were conducted in colonies under outsiders control. eg Mead's study in Somoa; Redcliffe-Brown's Veranda Anthropology in Andamans. (c) Imposition of fake and alien Categories on Colonies. eg Tutsi and Hutu in Rwanda; Caste in India

Shift with emergence of 20th Century 1. Franz Boas propounded Historical particularism and Cultural relativism, highlighting influence of unique contextual events on Cultures. 2. Malinowski put forward "participant observation" as a way to holistically understand a Culture. 3. M. Mead study of three babuan society highlighted the influence of different cultures on personality and vice versa. 4. Advancement in physical anthropology led to disregard of race concept. e.g. A. Montague's "Man's Greatest Myth"

Paradigm shift after World War 2 1. Influence of post modernism to deconstruct Colonial Knowledge 2. Reflexivity to analyse one's own biases. 3. "Collaborative research" to engage subjects in studies.

Hence, despite Colonial origins the changes show discipline's ability to self correct itself.