The principle of impartiality may conflict with the need for compassion towards marginalized communities. Discuss in the context of civil services in India.
Zinnia Aurora, AIR 6, 2025
Article 39(b) and 39(c) effectuate an equity-based dispensation ensuring social justice and economic proclivity to all.
Impartiality vs Compassion
| Impartiality | Compassion | |---|---| | rationality based decisions | Contextual understanding of problems | | Excess on 'objectivity' | suffering and emotive component high | | Rule-based governance | Role based governance | | Equality before law | Equal protection of laws (Article 14) | | Disregard for epistemic humility | humane understanding | | Cognitive supremacy | Affective supremacy |
1. Compassion with impartiality helps empower the poor - 'Are not all poor Gods too?' - Vivekananda 2. Provision of 'capabilities to all' -> Rawlsian justice requires balance of both 3. Intermixity of Cognitive rationality + affective care - eg. impartial implementation of PM-AWAS, MNREGA 4. Use of tools -> democratized reach of tools -> enable the last mile access - eg. Bank Mitras to provide same services of the bank as others get at branch
Thus, whilst nascently conflicting, impartiality and compassion serve 'welfare of all'.