Topper Copies

Q3. (a) Discuss the statement, “Culture is Superorganic”. (15 marks)

Utkarsh Ujjwal

E.B. Tylor, in PRIMITIVE CULTURE (1871) gave the evolutionary definition of culture as "a complex whole of knowledge, belief, customs, moral, art and law ACQUIRED by man as member of society".

The superorganic view of culture was propounded by Leslie white and Alfred Kroeber

PREMISE

"superorganic" refers to something that is above organic entities. Kroeber noted that culture can't be expressed as a function of any individual's behaviours. Rather, since culture is TRANSMISSIBLE and ADAPTIVE, it operates as per LAW its own i.e. culture is superindividual and superorganic.

Leslie white gave the Symbolic interpretation of culture and argued that it is "extra-somatic means of adaptation through which Man conveys his meanings"

He also gave following characteristics

(i) Man cannot control or affect the course of culture. It is a PASSIVE participant in cultural propagation

(ii) Culture cannot be analysed by human terms because it is above the human

CRITICISM

(i) Reduced role of humans in affecting culture was criticised

(ii) Edward Sapir called man an active element of culture

(iii) Ruth Benedict in Patterns of culture (1934) highlighted that culture is "Personality writ large" i.e personality does affect culture.

(iv) Such view can be refused to justify human right violation as part of cultural practice eg Genital mutilation in Dawoodi women

Superorganic view of culture has lost its relevance due to proof of interdependence of man and his culture. Cultures must not be allowed to continue violation of right in name of cultural relativism.