(c) Briefly discuss nature, meaning and scope of Political Anthropology. Also Differentiate between Primitive and Modern Law. (15 marks)
Utkarsh Ujjwal
Political Anthropology is a sub-branch of socio cultural anthropology that studies administration, laws, division of powers and authority as a socio-cultural phenomenon.
PIONEER WORK
(i) African political System (1940) by Meyer Fortes discussed how political organisation in primitive societies is different from modern societies
(ii) Political System of Highland Burma (1954) by Edmund Leach
NATURE
- Studies the Organisation of people in primitive societies and how authority is ensured - law and justice in simple societies - Conflict resolution
SCOPE
(i) The discipline helps us understand how tribal laws are based in their culture and are aimed at restoring societal harmony rather than punishing culprit
(ii) Laws are codified rules enacted by someone in authority the deviation from which attracts penal action
| Primitive | Modern | |---|---| | aim at ensuring social harmony | aim at punishing the culprit | | enforced by leaders (chief) | enforced by dedicated bureaucracy | | social sanctions | fines, imprisonment | | locus of authority can be diffused | | | mostly charismatic, hereditary authority eg: chiefdom | mostly constitutional (legal) authority |
Subramanian Natchappan committee (2016) noted that efforts to impose burden laws on tribal fail due to
The committee recommended to setup a "Tribal Judicial authority" to integrate both laws.
Today, political anthropology has helped policymakers understand the issue of legalism and intervention.