(b) Critically examine the debate between Formalists and Substantivists. (20 marks)
Utkarsh Ujjwal
The debate between formalist and substantivist school of thought is regarding the nature of economic models that can be applied to primitive societies
ORIGIN of debate
(i) Malinowski's 'Argonauts of Western Pacific' (1922) noted the presence of Kula exchange which assumed little economic significance.
(ii) Marcel Mauss in "The Gift" (1924) also noted presence of ceremonial exchange and called them "Total Prestations".
(iii) Karl Polanyi in "The Great Transformation" (1944) advanced their theory and started the substantivist school of thought.
(iv) As a response, formalist school emerged in 2nd half of 20th Century
BASIC PREMISE
| Formalist | Substantivist | |---|---| | Schneider, Herskovitz | M. Sahlins, Dalton | | Belief in modern economic models to apply to primitive societies | Concept of EMBEDDEDNESS: The Economy is embedded in social and kinship based matrix |
Assumptions
Formalist: 1. Principle of utility maximization weds scarce means 2. Principle of diminishing marginal utility 3. Human beings have infinite needs and always strive to gain profit for self
Substantivist - primitive societies have economy guided by: 1. Reciprocity
2. Redistribution 3. Primitive markets based on barter 4. Ceremonial exchange
CASE
(i) Robert Carneiro studied Bushmen (Africa) to find that they work ~3-4 hrs per day despite earning less than their potential. He concluded that their economic principles are guided by social unity and order in kinship.
(ii) Kula Exchange (malinowski) where Trobrianders undertake a dangerous voyages without any economic gain
(iii) Chenchu tribes don't kill female animals due to fear of their female deity GARELSANA. Also, even during food shortage, a portion is given to deity
CRITICISM
(i) Formalist's → Sahlins noted that "tribes are optimisers and not maximisers" and said money is of no significance to most primitive societies → Prevalance of Barter System among many tribes
[a horizontal diagram connecting Kinship, an illegible middle label, and Barter]
(ii) Substantivist → Polanyi criticised that today, no society is completely primitive and conditions of resource paucity exist everywhere. → Due to penetration of money economy, many tribes are directly participating in monetary exchanges eg] Baigas sell NTFPs in weekly haats
As an opposition to two schools, Goddlier and Terry propounded the MARKIST school of economic exchange.
Paul and Laura Bohannan, during their study of Tiv (Nigeria) noted that there is a shift towards transformation due to rising globalisation.
Today, the debate has lost its prominence due to an integrated approach. Amartya Sen's 'welfare economics' can be of help to understand primitive economy.