Elucidate the relevance of the concept of cultural relativism in the context of ethnographic fieldwork.
Harsh Nehara, AIR 74, 2025
Coined by Alain Locke and defined by Franz Boas in "Race language and Culture (1910)" as objective study of Cultures in their context without Cross Cultural Comparison is Cultural relativism.
Features of Cultural relativism 1. Each Culture evolved under influence of their unique historical process 2. There are limited ethical universals 3. The observer must try to understand Culture from natives perspective rather than his own
Types of Cultural relativism
| Absolute | Non-absolute | |---|---| | Justify all practices | Observer delay Judgement until full understanding |
Relevance in Ethnographic fieldwork
Ethnographic fieldwork is the method by which anthropologists collect data about cultures while living among them. It is Sine qua non for Anthropology.
Relevance 1. To understand true meaning of cultural events Eg Kula ceremony not a wasteful activity but one which binds trobrianders and fulfils needs 2. To avoid imposition of outsiders perspective on natives. Eg Evolutionists misunderstood spatial distance as temporal ones and made categories: Savage → Barbarism → Civilizations 3. To bring a holistic picture of culture to the World. Eg Mead's study on personality development in three societies. 4. To understand role of environment in shaping Culture. eg Kong have little clothes due to their surroundings. 5. To bring out and understand different interlinks within Cultural components eg Roy Rappaport's study of pig slaughtering 6. To build a rapport with subjects and avoid hostility. [challenges in ethnographic fieldwork: culture shock to the observer, and subjects conscious of the observer's presence]
Thus Cultural relativism and fieldwork are two ways to truly create and train an anthropologist as reminded by M. Mead