Topper Copies

While accountability often necessitates documentation, an overemphasis on bureaucratic procedures and excessive paperwork can inadvertently silence the very voices that public policy intends to empower, particularly at the grassroots. Examine the above statement with suitable illustrations.

Zinnia Aurora, AIR 6, 2025

Procedural accountability must be balanced with substantive justice to lay a figurative 'welfare state' (Article 38)

Issues with overemphasis

1. Rule based governance undermines 'role' of civil servant - eg. Death of 2 due to 'technicality' citing for ration card in Jharkhand 2. Compassion as compass for accountability - eg. PM Awas - roof provision led to removal of roofs to claim benefits -> living on road 3. Proactive thinking and action by civil servant -> Going beyond 'letter' and into 'spirit' of laws 4. Documentation as means, not the end in itself - eg. Deontological ethics applied by PM Modi by sitting down to meet a parathawala 5. Balance Weberian bureaucracy with Bentham's 'benevolent guardian' -> add 'public' to public servant 6. 'Wooden, rigid bureaucracy' at the altar of accountability -> secularised, open nature to connect with people

However, accountability is also crucial:

Accountability and compassion are the two wheels of an 'austere and able' civil service (President Murmu)