Topper Copies

Reciprocity and redistribution with ethnographic examples.

Harsh Nehara, AIR 74, 2025

Karl Polanyi in his "The Great Transformation (1944)" highlighted three forms of exchange in simple society: Reciprocity, Redistribution, Market

Reciprocity: refers to a form of exchange undertaken without any medium of exchange.

Sahlins divided in three forms

Generalised reciprocity exchange without obligation or expectation of return. Eg Hopi red Indians; Bemba when sister gives birth; Philanthropy

Balanced reciprocity exchange with an obligation and expectation of equal return, no bargain is allowed Eg Between blacksmith and Raji of Uttarakhand; Between Vedder and Sinhalese.

Negative reciprocity trying to get maximum while offering minimum in return Eg Trade between Navajo and European settlers

Significance - Create and Strengthen social bonds - Negative reciprocity [illegible] brought by deficit hostility - Circulation of wealth without medium of exchange

Redistribution: Polanyi define it as movement of Goods and services towards centre of authority and their subsequent distribution

Examples - The Raja chief performs beto - Potlatch among Kwakiutl. - "Pig feasts" in melanesia.

Significance → signify hierarchy; rule of minority over majority; equalisation mechanism.

However, institutions are not static and the market are gradually getting hold of traditional economies as well.