Q.2 (a) "The concepts of Tribe and Caste in India have often been placed on a continuum rather than as two discrete categories." Critically examine this statement with suitable ethnographic examples.
Gudelli Srujana, AIR 55, 2025
F. G. Bailey gave the Tribe-caste continuum inspired from Robert Redfield's folk-urban continuum.
Tribe-caste continuum 1. It says that Tribe and caste are two separate entities (polar ideals) which do not exist in reality. 2. Rather they are not mutually exclusive and present on a continuum.
[a horizontal continuum diagram from Tribe to Caste, marking Khonds and Oriyas along it]
3. The study done by F.G. Bailey on the Bisipara Village found that: - (i) The Khonds have tribe like features in culture. - (ii) Oriyas followed the caste like features. 4. Characteristics of a tribe: - (i) Isolation geographically. - (ii) Small population. - (iii) Nature based worship and customs. - Ex: Chenchus of Andhra. 5. Characteristics of a caste: - (i) Forms a large society. - (ii) Modern society. - (iii) Divisions as given by G.S. Ghurye. - Religious and civil disabilities, endogamy, etc. 6. Surajit Sinha studied the tribes of Odisha and found that there is: - (i) Always an element of caste in tribes. - (ii) Element of tribes in caste. 7. Sachidananda gave a list of 30 traits to identify whether it is a tribe or caste.
Case study The study done by Surajit Sinha among the tribes of Odisha - Oraons, they are tribes but they follow cultures of mainstream also, for example, worshipping Hindu Gods.
Criticisms 1. Resistance of the Tribal communities. - Ex: The Gond rebellion. 2. Endangers the culture of the tribes. - Ex: According to PLSI, 400 languages are endangered in India. 3. It is not always an overharmonious picture. - Ex: B.K. Roy Burman's study of the tribes' exploitation. 4. The pressure of conversion of the tribes to mainstream. - Ex: Christian missionaries in Chattisgarh.
The Tribe-caste continuum concept emerged as a result of indigenous village studies in anthropology countering colonial narrative.