Topper Copies

How do descent theories and alliance theories differ in their approaches to understanding kinship and social organization?

Harsh Nehara, AIR 74, 2025

Kinship refers to the study of how certain individuals of a society associate themselves with others.

L.H. Morgan's "Systems of Consanguinity and affinity in primitive societies" is responsible for igniting interest in kinship studies

Descent and Alliance theories aim to explain how kinship is established in a society.

(A) Descent theorists view (i) Propounded by Radcliffe Brown and Edmund Leach. (ii) Consider the bond of blood as the reason of kinship. (iii) This bond leads to the Creation of unilineal descent groups in the society eg Lineages. (iv) Edmund Leach's study of Tallensi of Ghana Affiliation: establish legitimacy of child traced through both parents.

[a descent diagram headed "Clan", contrasting a demonstrated-descent branch with an assumed-descent branch, bracketed "Lineages" and captioned "Bonds in unilineal descent groups"]

Descent: (i) traced only from father. (ii) individual considered part of a larger group and no separate identity of own apart from group. (v) consider marriage to be of [illegible], related to individual only.

(B) Alliance theory (i) Backed by Levi's Strauss. (ii) The dichotomy of 'us' Vs 'them' is managed through the exchange of women (iii) It is the greatest form of exchange that created bonds which lasts several generations (iv) It reduces hostility and lead to the formation of Kin groups. (v) Incest taboo is a "pre-social social fact" that enable exchange between groups leading to formation of society.

Criticism

A new view that is Janet Carsten's "concept of relatedness" has emerged that view action rather than biology as an explanation of Kinship.

These different views aid us in understanding Kinship System holistically