Topper Copies

What are the two main schools in economic anthropology? What are the fundamental differences in their approach to the study of economic systems in simple societies? (20 marks)

Asad Zuberi

Formalism and Substantivism are the two main schools in economic Anthropology which seeks to study economics of simple and complex societies.

Formalism - M. Herskovits and K. Schneider are main proponents of formalist school. - Basic idea: 1. Laws of neoclassical economics can be universally applied to all i.e simple as well as complex economies with some modifications. 2. When economic decisions are taken, they lie largely in economic spheres.

Criticism 1. J. Prattis marked that universality of Utility Maximization cannot be justified

fig: Formalism

Substantivism → Proponents: Karl Polanyi, M. Sahlins, G Dalton,

Basic Idea: Karl Polanyi in 'Great Transformation (1944)' marks that the economic decisions in simple Societies also considers themselves with Social spheres and not solely economic sphere.

Criticism - J Prattis and Plattner maintained that a strict division between simple and complex economies is not possible in contemporary societies.

Fundamental differences in approach

1. Decision Making - Formalism: Proposes that this is largely effected by utility Maximization - Substantivism: Proposes that this is affected by Social institutions like kinship, religion, etc 2. Universal applicability of laws - Formalism: Supports universal application of neo-classical economics - Substantivism: Proposes different applications for Simple and Complex economies. 3. Embeddedness: - Formalism: does not proposes embeddedness. - Substantivism: proposes embedded nature, where economy and social spheres are connected.

Example: B. Malinowski's study on Kula ring exchange shows meaningful application of Substantivism.

Karl Polanyi himself remarked that due to globalisation, both the concepts are applicable in both Simple and Complex Economies in fusion.