Discuss the rationale behind declaring Minimum Support Price (MSP) and various issues related to MSP regime in the country. Do you think that providing legal backing to MSP is necessary and sufficient for making farming financially sustainable?
Raghav Jhunjhunwala, AIR 4, 2025
MSP is a kind of assurance provided to farmers and acts as a price floor, which is critical in years of glut, as we become agri-surplus and have broken supply chains.
Rationale behind MSP 1. Food security: India's hunger situation is poor, ranked 107/121 on the GHI 2. Price support to farmers: esp. in years of good harvest, to prevent distress sale, esp. to small farmers 3. Indian agriculture has non-integrated supply chains: not possible for farmers to directly reach markets, esp. when avg. holding is 1.08 Ha. and there is less surplus with each farmer
MSP was initially theorized as exclusively for some years which needed support, and Procurement Price was announced for normal years. However, MSP became a habit post 2005 (Swaminathan Committee recommendation).
Issues with the MSP regime - Distorted production (Rice in Punjab, a semi-Arid zone) - Financially unsustainable and environmental degradation - Benefits usurped by large farmers (Eco Survey 2016-17)
Demand to 'legalize MSP' Cons: 1. Already our granaries are overflowing with just 2 crops: rice & wheat 2. Capacity of FCI in procurement 3. Subsidy bill would skyrocket (currently over 5 lakh cr. -> Agri)
But it might lead to agri-diversification, as other crops would get assured procurement.
But MSP is not the ultimate panacea 1. Output elasticity of investment in agriculture is far more than subsidy - Prof. Ramesh Chand. Need for public investment, as it reduces cost esp. for small farmers 2. Prof. Ashok Gulati: need to invest more in Agri. R&D, better quality seeds, etc. 3. Rural marketing and supply chain development ultimately decides price realization
Thus, overall reforms, and not merely a myopic approach on MSP, is the need of the hour, as proposed by Prof. Dalwai in the quest of doubling farmer income.