Topper Copies

Q7. (b) Culture is unique to human beings. Do you agree? Present arguments in favour and against the statement. (15 marks)

Tanuj Pathak, AIR 72, 2023

Culture as defined by Dr. Malinowski in his book "Argonauts of Western Pacific" 1922 is the handiwork of the man and the means to achieve his own ends.

Dr. Kroeber and Kluckhohn have defined culture as the totality of learnt human behavior, transmitted through social inheritance.

Anthropologists have envisioned culture as a pattern of learnt and shared behavior. Many animals in the wild show shared and learnt behavior. However, "distinct behavioral pattern" can only be shown by primates, that too great apes.

Let us examine various characteristics of culture and conclude if culture is unique to human or not.

1. Culture as learnt and shared behavior: Chimpanzees in wild are known to use sticks, leaves to sponge up water. Orangutans are known to use sticks to bring out termites. Their young ones learn using sticks through the adults. In this case culture is NOT unique to humans. 2. Use of language: language is very crucial for the transmission of culture via social inheritance. Although our nearest relatives do possess some rudimentary pre-culture ability of language (eg Jane Goodall and gestural communication by Chimpanzees), no other genus other than human can use language to the extent of humans. In terms of language, it is strictly limited to human. 3. Culture is adaptive: changing environment and needs changes culture. Only humans can quickly adapt to the changing environment. This is missing in great apes. In this sense too culture is strictly a human capacity. 4. Moral foundation in Culture: culture also guides the individual what is good and what is bad. Moral elements are missing in monkeys and great apes. In terms of moral foundation too culture is a strict human capacity.

Hence, taking into account all the factors we can say that though our nearest relatives do possess some kind of rudimentary pre-culture/proto-culture abilities, the culture that anthropologists have envisioned is strictly a human capacity. Culture is UNIQUE to Humans.