Topper Copies

Discuss the significance of objectivity in anthropological research and why it remains elusive.

Alase Hrishikesh Rajendra, AIR 61, 2025

Objectivity refers to collection, analysis, interpretation and presentation of anthropological data purely based on the merits of the case, i.e. without any bias.

Essentiality of objectivity 1. Ensures that anthropological study is empirical in nature and representative of ground reality. 2. Prevents confirmation bias and can act as a fine test of anthropological theories. 3. Ensures higher effectiveness of [?] applied and action anthropology, e.g. PRA.

How objectivity is elusive 1. Non-participant observation or Veranda fieldwork: merely data collection without rapport building leads to misrepresentation of fact. 2. Investigator bias: in classical school, many fieldnotes were marred with confirmation bias of [?] researchers. 3. Translation error: Margaret Mead was criticised for failing to learn Samoan language, leading to translation errors. 4. Hawthorne effect: informants generally change their behaviour and answers due to peer pressure etc. 5. Rivals issue: when only one side of argument is presented. Eg: Beteille's study. 6. Extreme reflexivity has been criticised for shifting the focus from informant to researcher. Eg: Focault's study. 7. Post-modern school argues that there is no such thing as objectivity, as 'truth' is merely a construct of power.

Despite the criticism, objectivity has been the factor that has shaped anthropology into an empirical, scientific study.