Trace the evolution of fieldwork as an anthropological research technique, discuss the contemporary changes in it, and the criticisms levelled against it.
Alase Hrishikesh Rajendra, AIR 61, 2025
Fieldwork is a technique of primary data collection in which the investigator stays for a long time and collects data directly from the informant.
Evolution of fieldwork 1. First carried out by L.H. Morgan among Iroquois Indians. 2. Observation (non-participant) was used by Radcliffe-Brown during his study of 'Onge of the Andamanese'. 3. Inductive method was propounded by Franz Boas during his study of Kwakiutl. 4. Malinowski, during his study of Trobrianders, introduced the concept of participant observation. 5. Till now the fieldwork has been androcentric; Ruth Benedict's study of Pueblo-Zuni and Mead's study of Samoans introduced feminist fieldwork. 6. Post-modern era saw the entry of the post-modern school, which introduced deconstruction (Derrida), reflexivity and multi-sited fieldwork.
Contemporary changes 1. The definition of the field has changed from exotic island to even oneself and internet. Eg: Auto-ethnography: 'Coming of Age in Internet' by Tom Boellstorff. 2. Cross-cultural comparisons has increased due to easier access to ethnographic data. Eg: Human Relations Area File (HRAF). 3. Introduction of new tools such as 'The Ethnography', 'Atlas ti' or 'Questionnaire'. 4. Inclusion of new multimedia techniques for data collection. Eg: Videography.
Criticisms 1. Ethical: a. Idea of consent is missing among fieldwork to present. b. Confidentiality and privacy of community, to prevent from stereotyping. c. Utility: fieldwork studies have been used for exploitation. Eg: colonial studies. d. Method of presentation of data: sensationalisation or scientific studies. 2. Hawthorne effect impacts accuracy of data. Eg: Peer pressure. 3. Role availability: many times investigators feel like intruders in the culture, as small stay is not enough to build rapport. 4. Cultural shock: as was the case of Malinowski and his diary. 5. Racial issue: when only one community dominates research. Eg: Brahmins in Andre Beteille's study.
Despite the criticism, due to its immense utility, fieldwork has been the hallmark of anthropology and adopted by other disciplines.