Topper Copies

Q2. (a) What are the two main schools in economic anthropology? What are the fundamental differences in their approach to the study of economic systems in simple societies? (20 marks)

Tanuj Pathak, AIR 72, 2023

Economic Anthropology can be defined as the cross cultural analysis of economies of societies across the world.

It was the pioneering work of Dr. Malinowski in Trobriand Islands which attracted the attention of Anthropologists to study the economic activities of simple societies.

Dr. Karl Polanyi in his book "The Great Transformation" has noted two schools in economic anthropology: (i) Formalist School and (ii) Substantivist school.

Formalist school Famous formalists are Dr. Schneider, Dr. Herskovits and Dr. Raymond firth.

According to formalist school: 1. Every individual takes his decision rationally. He uses all the information available to this, makes proper calculations and then takes economic decisions. 2. Everybody lives in scarcity of resources and unlimited wants. 3. People feel satisfaction in saving scarce resources and profit maximization.

That is, all the fundamentals of economics are applicable to tribal economies/simple societies too.

Criticism 1. Prattis has said this view to be tautological, i.e. if someone sacrifices his time and health to help other, formalists will say he is adding value to helping others. 2. Economic view that does not consider social relations is bound to be flawed.

Substantivist view Leading proponents of this view are Dr. Karl Polanyi, Sahlins, etc.

According to Dr. Polanyi, social relations of the people need to be considered while studying their economic activities.

According to Dr. Mark Granovetter, the economic transactions of simple societies are embedded in their social relations with each other.

For example, in Kula ring described by Dr. Malinowski, people risk their lives and take dangerous voyages (to exchange economically relevant items). However due to this exchange their kinship bonds get stronger.

Dr Sahlins has commented that simple societies do not maximise, they optimise. - In the current world, there is hardly any pre-industrial society left - Scarcity of resources can happen anywhere and anytime

After Globalization, the simple economies too are moving towards the modern economies. Time is right to apply an interdisciplinary approach; both formalists and substantivists need to come together to study the simple economies in these changing times.