Topper Copies

Critically analyze the historical debate on tribal development policy in independent India. Comment on the necessity and key challenges of adopting a rights-based approach in addressing current tribal development issues.

Rasneet Kaur, AIR 51, 2025

Tribes live in a symbiotic relation with nature and forests (NMS Complex of LP Vidyarthi). But this symbiotic relation got disrupted by colonial policies.

Therefore in Independent India, a debate started about the appropriate tribal development policy.

Debate on tribal development policy

I) Isolationist Approach -> This was advocated by Verrier Elwin in his book "The Baiga" (1939) -> It refers to that tribes must be prevented from contact with the outer world in order to preserve their unique culture and identity. Criticism -> Many nationalists and assimilationists like GS Ghurye termed it as "No changers" and "Status Quoists"

II) Assimilation Approach -> This was advocated by GS Ghurye. -> He referred to tribes as backward Hindus; therefore through assimilation their transformation is required. Criticism -> Verrier Elwin and Haimendorf say that primary cause behind tribal impoverishment is the contact with the outside world.

III) Integrationist Approach -> This is the approach finally adopted by India. -> It was advocated by PM Jawaharlal Nehru in the foreword of the book "A Philosophy for NEFA" -> It says that tribes must be allowed to develop according to their own terms. -> Tribal Panchsheel is result of this approach. Criticism -> LP Vidyarthi said that principles of Tribal Panchsheel are not followed in full spirit

Necessity of adopting a rights-based approach 1. Tribes facing multidimensional issues: loss of livelihood, low health indicators, illiteracy, land alienation, poverty, indebtedness 2. It is also needed to undo the historical injustice they faced in the form of colonial exploitation. 3. Forest Conservation and Management can also be ensured through this rights-based approach Eg Joint Forest Management as advocated in Forest Policy, 1988 4. Study -> Nearly 47% of all displaced due to development are tribals while they constitute only 8% of total population.

Key challenges 1. Lack of proper implementation Eg Xaxa Committee -> only 15% FRA claims have been accepted. 2. Illiteracy leads to unawareness among the tribes about their rights -> only 59% literacy rate among tribes 3. Lack of standardization Eg difficulty in FRA claim approval due to lack of evidence or documents

Way forward 1. Proper implementation of existing policies: PESA, 1996; FRA, 2006; Land Acquisition Act, 2013 2. BD Sharma said that anthropological approach needs to be adopted for inclusive tribal development