Topper Copies

Evaluate the significance of the PM-JANMAN scheme in addressing the challenges faced by Particularly Vulnerable Tribal Groups (PVTGs) in India. Discuss the hurdles to its implementation and propose strategies for ensuring its effective impact.

Rasneet Kaur, AIR 51, 2025

PVTGs were first identified by Dhebbhar Commission as PTGs, that is primitive tribal groups.

In 2006, nomenclature was changed to PVTGs to refer to the most vulnerable among the tribals.

Currently there are 75 PVTGs in India in 18 states.

Examples -> Mankidia, Juangs (Odisha); Chenchus (Andhra); Konyak Nagas (Nagaland)

Various challenges faced by PVTGs in India 1. Low levels of literacy. 2. Pre-agricultural level of technology -> leads to agricultural distress. 3. Stagnant and declining population 4. Displacement and alienation Eg Juangs of Odisha suffered displacement due to Simlipal Tiger Reserve. 5. Low health indicators Nearly 61% of PVTG women are anaemic.

In this light, GoI launched PM-JANMAN scheme.

Significance of PM-JANMAN 1. Holistic and comprehensive development, branching into health, education, sanitation and water supply 2. Provision for Residence -> provides for pucca houses for PVTGs. 3. Capability Approach -> This scheme utilizes collaboration with private sector for tribal development. Eg GOAL in partnership with Facebook for digitally skilling the tribal youth. 4. Umbrella Scheme for PVTGs -> combines other schemes like Van Dhan Yojna, PM AJAY etc. 5. In line with Tribal Panchsheel Approach

Some hurdles in its implementation 1. Exclusion -> Many tribes fulfilling the criteria for PVTGs have not been included. 2. Corruption and leakage -> Scheme is pursued only in letter, not in spirit. 3. Unawareness among PVTGs about their rights. 4. Lack of Anthropological Approach leads to insensitivity for PVTG needs. 5. Many PVTGs reel under the stigma of "criminal tribes"

Xaxa Recommendations (2013) 1. Priority to PVTG needs in any tribal development policies. 2. FRA rights of PVTG must be given priority 3. Other strategies: advocated for anthropological training to the bureaucracy for better implementation of schemes like JANMAN.

Thus PM-JANMAN must be implemented in the true spirit of Tribal Panchsheel.