Topper Copies

Q6. (a) Critically analyse the Impact of Modern Democratic Institutions on Tribal areas.

Ayushi Pradhan, AIR 36, 2023

After Independence, policy of integrationist in line with tribal panchsheel was followed. This led to introduction of various modern democratic institution in tribal areas.

Impact of Modern Democratic Institutions 1. Better living standard among tribals - Integration in Modern economy Case study: Centre for Science and environment People's forest report, woman from sheopanshwar wildlife sanctuary exposed 96000 MT worth of bamboo, earning 18 Cr profit 2. Right to land and self governance upheld Case study: Niyamgiri project was halted by Supreme Court after Gram Sabha rejection 3. ITDP, TRIFED → Better education and health facilities among tribals Eg ITDP working for their skill development in tailoring Eg TRIFED - Tribal scheme (Van dhan yojana). Konda tribal of odisha making dona pattas and sending to Tirupati Devasthanam

Negative Impact 1. Increased conflict between traditional political system and modern PRI Case study: Karishma Reddy in study of Konda Reddies in Khammam district found opposition to modern PRI 2. Breakdown of traditional socio-cultural institution, change in roles and relationship leading to alteration of social structure 3. Decline of youth dormitory among Ho - disappearance of useful traits 4. Economic sustinence pattern impacted - rise of monetized system, rising land alienation and lack of proper rehabilitation Case study: Hatia Industrial complex uprooted 100, [?] Mundas, santal and 40% of the lands given in Compensation were wasteland 5. Loss of traditional culture and adoption of great tradition Eg Leela Dube notes the adoption of shariat law among tribes of Lakshadweep due to Islamic influence 6. Rising tribal protest due to discontent from govt Eg Pathalgadi movement in Jharkhand due to frequent changes in land tenancy laws

Overall, as mentioned by [?] Chaudhary in "An introduction to tribal transformation in India", there is lack of felt need approach, thus tribal panchsheel has remained just on paper.

This needs a radical shift in our vision of national development to realign it with tribal interests.