Topper Copies

5) Write a note of 150 words on the following: (10x5=50) (a) Ghurye-Elwin debate on tribe (b) Gandhi and tribes (c) Pseudo-tribalism (d) Tribal Sub-plan (e) Urbanisation and tribal institutions

Ayushi Pradhan, AIR 36, 2023

(a) Ghurye-Elwin debate on tribe

After Independence Ghureye and Elwin proposed 2 contrasting approach to tribal development - isolationism by elwin and assimilation by Ghureye.

Approach 1. Elwin proposed National park model or complete isolation in the Aborginals. Ghureye considered tribals as Backward bands and advocated complete assimilation of tribals for development 2. Classification - Elwin → Type 1: Completely Isolated, Type 2: Partial Contact, Type 3: In contact but marginalized, Type 4: In contact & dominated - Elwin advocated Isolate Type 1 & 2 so that they become type 4 who undergoing Type 3 - Ghureye → Type 1: Some completely assimilated, Type 2: partial contact, Type 3: ad: Isolation - Type 3 and 2 → should aim for type 1

Criticism 1. Elwin's approach → fossilized view of tribe, only for academic interest (A.V Thakkar, Ghureye) 2. Ghureye - S C Dube and Vidyarthi criticized for monolithic view of tribal groups are diversities

To resolve between the conflicting view, middle ground in form of integrationist approach was proposed by JL Nehru in "the Philosophy for the NEFA" (1958) - Tribal Panchsheel policies.

(b) Gandhi and tribes

Gandhi advocated for egalitarian model of development, with self-governance and self sufficiency. This is inherent in the way tribes organize themselves.

Common Principles of Gandhi and Tribes 1. Idea of Gram swaraj - self Governance → a vital aspect of identity for tribal ([?] committee) 2. Economy - small scale and khadi similar to tribes' less sophisticated simple economy 3. Egalitarian view of Gandhi find reflection in tribes' social structure

Gandhi principles for tribal development 1. Gandhiji relied on participant observation and emic viewpoint. Eg Champaran Satyagraha 2. Gandhiji relied on extensive fieldwork across all india tour 3. Gandhian - self subsistence economy model - basis for FRA recognition of forests, minor forest produce

Thus Gandhian model of development finds reflection in current model of Tribal panchsheel which lets the tribals to develop their own genius, instead of imposing any culture on them.

(c) Pseudo-tribalism

Pseudo tribalism refers to a phenomenon of many tribes falsely claiming tribal status to get benefits.

Methods of Pseudotribalization 1. Same and Confusing name. Eg Paul Ekka caste → posing as Taukala tribe 2. Retribalization

3. Tribalization and Desanskritisation. Many lower caste adopting tribal mores and rituals and claiming tribal status (H S Singh). Eg D.N. Majumdar's Chor Ka Ch[?]gaon (1960)

4. Tribe Caste Continuum: close interaction has led many caste posing as tribe. Eg study of Badaga caste by Paul Hockings

Currently due to reservation benefits, [?] like Gujjars have accelerated their demand (Rajasthan).

Pseudotribalism leads to cornering of actual beneficiary's and thus needs to be checked.

(d) Tribal Sub-plan

Tribal sub plan was conceived in 5th Five Year plan on recommendation of Expert Committee on tribal development led by [?] and scouse.

Objective and process - Funds to be allocated in % of tribal population - Proper ITDP administrative structure for holistic development of tribe - education, skill - Specific tribal program to be implemented - Done in area >50% of tribal population but <60% - Rise in female literacy rate from 1.8% in 1978 to 65% in 2011 - ITDP criteria: Bharya development agency - Strawberry plantation in sunebada

Negative 1. Ramesh Boi's - decreasing outlay of fund 2. CAG 2015 - diversion of fund. Case study: Koroda district was only 1.8% of ST out 36% TSP fund goes there, fund diverted to constitute Bhubaneswar fly over 3. [?] charge → lack of consultation with local - Fund is not divided into district, block etc - It was supposed to be non lapsable, however it is diverted

TSP funds need to be utilized in proper judicious manner to achieve goals of Tribal Panchsheel.

(e) Urbanisation and tribal institutions

Urbanisation refers to the migration in urban areas, which has led to significant change in tribal's social structure and institution.

[a rising line graph, census 2011: percentage of urbanisation among tribals, 1% in 1971, 3% in 1991, 7% in 2001, 11% in 2011]

Impact of urbanisation on tribal institutions 1. Political institution: Decline of traditional political leadership 2. Sociocultural: Decline of gender dormitories. Case study: P.K Dayuphta in study of Chaibasa cement work notes increased migration to urban areas. This has led to decline of celebration of traditional Naga festival among Ho's 3. Religions: traditional belief system impacted, rise of Hinduization due to increased contact. Eg Pranab Bansode study among Gond (2018) → urbanization led to increased contact w/cities, Hinduization, decline in Bride price 4. Economic constitution: shift toward monetised economy, principle of self sufficiency and reciprocity break down. Urbanisation of Barmans of Assam - Dimasa migrated to Silchar town, started living in joint family, but soon shifted to Nuclear. Traditional ritual and entertainment system broke, along with non reciprocity and monetized economy

Urbanization is leading to sort of Cultural mutation among tribal impacting all the social institution.