Topper Copies

4.c) Discuss the rise of ethno-nationalism among Indian tribes keeping in mind Manipur conflict.

Ayushi Pradhan, AIR 36, 2023

Ethnonationalism refers to the phenomenon where the ethnic identity takes the shape of political movement, demanding the formation of new area/state based on ethnic identity.

Rise of ethnonationalism 1. Primordial: Rise is due to cultural and kinship bond among people belonging to same ethnic identity (C. Geertz). Eg Nagaland movement 2. Instrumentalist (Paul Brass, A Cohen): Ethnonationalism arises to fulfill certain interest of the political elite. Eg Khalistan (Akali dal political Interest) 3. Constructivism (Weinland): ethnonationalism arises when people decide to be mobilized on certain issues for some economic or social gain, thus it is not completely in the hand of political elites or leader

Manifest Conflict analysis 1. Can be seen as form of Constructivism 2. Through manifest cause seems ethnic difference between Kuki and [?] Meity, however latent cause includes economic issue 3. Manifest: High court decision to give ST status to Meity, created fear of economic domination by Kuki, which acted as a trigger point 4. Removal of illegal encroachment of Kuki's, demarcation of Manipur legislative assembly may merely lead to further increase in distrust among the Communities

As mentioned by NK Das in critique of "nation building and redistributive justice" (2009), demands of the people need not be seen always as bad, they are often due to disparity in developmental process, we need to ensure redistributive Justice.