1) Write a note of 150 words on the following: (10x5=50) (a) Concept of tribe and Indian census (b) Contribution of Christoph von Fürer-Haimendorf to Tribal India (c) Tribe-Caste continuum (d) Impact of Islam on Indian Tribes (e) Problem of Land Alienation among tribal
Ayushi Pradhan, AIR 36, 2023
(a) Concept of tribe and Indian census
Tribe was a socially created construct that came to be defined in the Indian Census by the Britishers.
Tribe and Indian Census – evolution 1. 1881: Tribes were considered a subcategory under Pastoral Caste 2. 1901: Religion → Animism linkage was brought. Concept of hill and forest tribe 3. 1921: considered as primitive tribe 4. 1931: Backward tribe 5. 1951: Kalekar commission based on backward tribe identified 427 tribes 6. Lokur committee: 5 criteria for classification of tribe
Later, area restriction was removed; now for tribe to be recognized as ST, no set area conditions.
Importance of recording traibe in census 1. To provide reservation under 366(25) 2. Educational benefit: 59% literacy rate of tribal 3. Data about poverty and socioeconomic condition 4. Based on population → TDP formation in area >50% of population, TSP fund allocation in proportion to population
Concept of tribe evolved with the enumeration process of the census. Currently the data provided by the census is used for socioeconomic development of the traibe.
(b) Contribution of Christoph von Fürer-Haimendorf to Tribal India
Christoph Haimendorf was an Austrian ethnologist influenced by Elwin, James Hutton and Malinowski.
Literary contribution - The Chenchus (1943) - The Naked Nagas - The Sherpas - Naked Nagas of Assam (1970) - Raj Gonds of Adilabad - The Reddis of Bison Hill
Methodological contribution - He introduced visual anthropology, eg videos of Sherpa, Naga - Action anthropology: eg fought for the rights of Gond, gave Haimendorf Patta
Contribution to tribal studies 1. Use of language: learnt Nagalism to study Naga 2. Detailed ethnography: of Naga, Sherpas, Apatani 3. Studied changes in tribal culture: in Tribes of India's, Struggle for Survival (1982) 4. Analyzed the reason for regionalism: CRPC imposed [?] on (144) on Gonds led to discontent and demand for separate Gondaland 5. Studied Apatani's [?] tribe and found many Apatanis studying in university and progress among them 6. Appointed as advisor to Nizam. [?] opened schools for Gonds - education in Gondi language
Haimendorf through his altruistic and empathetic studies about tribes, have played a crucial role in upholding tribal rights.
(c) Tribe-Caste continuum
Tribe caste continuum was proposed by F.G Bailey in "Tribe, caste and nation" influenced by Redfield folk urban continuum.
Concept - Tribes and caste are not to be considered as a polar category - Rather, there is continuous degree of interaction between tribe and caste and they show continuum of traits
Case study → F.G Bailey in study of Bisipura found Konda tribals had caste like features like they employed "Panas" for cleaning purpose (similar to Jajmani system of Caste)
Reason for Tribe caste Continuum 1. Ecological: David Mandelbaum - due to ecological pressure tribals migrated to village 2. Hinduization - NK Bose in "Hindu method of tribal absorption" mentions how tribals were attracted to the hindu style of tribe Juang 3. Rising tribalization - KS Singh mentions about lower caste adopting tribal mores and rituals. Eg DN Majumdar in Chota ka ek gaon (1946) - found Brahmin, Thakur → emulating khasa
Criticism 1. TC Das in study of Kharia found revolt among the tribals about hindu style of living 2. [?] criticized ecno centric biasedness in just considering tribes adopting caste feature and ignoring the other way round
Tribe Caste Continuum shows the interaction between little tradition and great tradition resulting into a syncretic culture.
(d) Impact of Islam on Indian Tribes
Islam emerged in India with the rise of Indo Islamic rulers. Its egalitarian feature attracted the tribes the most.
Distribution - Mostly spread took place due to trade in Malabar coast
[a labelled outline map of India marking Bakkarwal and Gaddi, Khasis and Naga, Siddi, Koya, and Nayars as tribes where Islam spread]
Impact of Islam on Tribes 1. Case study: Impact of Islam on Tribes of Lakshadweep - Leela Dube, A.R Kutty - Decline in puberty rites - Rise of cross cousin marriage 2. Following Shari'at laws 3. Matriliny and Islam coexisted 4. Imdad Ali' - study of Islam in tribal tribes of North east - Khasi → the role of Kaddah (younger daughter) minimized - Naga → role of Father Azan - Bodo → utter Bismillah before festival 5. K Warikoo in "Bakharwaal tribe of J&K" (2000) - Found respect for sufi saint - Coexistence of Islam with their tribal tradition
Thus Islam has not completely replaced tribal religion, but there is interaction of greater and lesser tradition resulting into Syncretism.
(e) Problem of Land Alienation among tribal
As per Fernandes, out of all the project affected persons, 43% are tribals. This reveals the extent of land alienation among Tribal.
Cause of land alienation 1. Constitutional provision: eg 5th schedule, 6th schedule, PESA, LARRA 2013 is often bypassed - clause of eminent domain in LARRA 2013 Case study: Anupam Chakraborty (2015) found forging of 11000 signatures of Baiga in Gramsabha to set up Mahan coal field in Singrauli district of west Bengal 2. Rising indebtedness among tribe → land transfer Case study: Kamel K Mishra (2002) found tribal to non tribal land transfer as 85.5% 3. Rising conflict, eg Naxal-maga conflict → agro displacement 4. Developmental projects and national parks, eg Narmedia tribal displacement from Semleipal national park
Impact of land alienation 1. Marginalization of tribal 2. Poverty and Indebtness 3. Loss of community network 4. Loss of education 5. Poor health and nutrition 6. Loss of livelihood
Case study: Parasuram (1999) in study of Bolangir tribes in Keonjhar found even once self sufficient community were pauperized.
There is need to involve tribal in Benefit sharing decision (Brazil model) or to implement land leasing model of Japan.