08. (a) Rapid depletion of forest resources is the major cause of pauperization in tribes. In this context critically evaluate Forest laws of Indian government post-independence.
Rajput Neha Uddhavsingh, AIR 51, 2023
The deforestation and industrialisation has led to the loss of livelihood of many tribal people & thus a major cause of pauperisation of tribes.
The forest laws post-independence:
1. Forest Rights Act, 2006: this Act has been major in safeguarding land & restoring rights.
It empowers the Gram Sabha to identify individuals for rights to be granted; any plan approved goes through it, and the Gram Sabha helps prevent land alienation.
Critical evaluation: the law has flaws and lacunae, compounded with improper implementation. 1. Many people have been denied the rights because of no proper documentation. 2. The process of obtaining those rights is tedious. 3. Until now, only 15% of people have been granted these rights. 4. Despite its powers, Gram Sabhas are overridden by the rulings/decisions of the state machinery. Eg in Meghalaya, the acts of the state legislature would supersede those of the Autonomous Council/Gram Sabhas (12A Section).
2. Land Acquisition Act, 2013: this Act had aimed to protect the forest land holdings of the tribals, framed comprehensively to address issues.
Critical evaluation: 1. Though it provides fair compensation and Resettlement & Rehabilitation, the Act is a regressive one; rather than limiting land acquisition, it facilitates acquisition by private companies, by making it easy. 2. Land for land is provided only when the government is acquiring the land. 3. When land is acquired through a public-private partnership, it's a backdoor to less compensation.
Thus, despite the forest laws, it has been the norm to displace the tribes in the name of development, and then the depletion of resources deprives them of their right to livelihood.