Q7. (a) Lack of tribal development not because of absence of policies, it is about the missing dialogue between Adivasis and those who are required to think about them. Elaborate.
Rajput Neha Uddhavsingh, AIR 51, 2023
The Indian Constitution, in letter and spirit, has always upheld the rights & safeguards of tribals. The Tribal Panchsheel is an example of our policy towards the tribals.
Some of the policies and legislations for tribals:
1. National Resettlement and Rehabilitation Policy, 2007: this policy provides a comprehensive framework to prevent land alienation and displacement.
Criticism: 1. Despite the intention of rehabilitation being an integral part of the development process, lack of apathy & communication with tribal people means local authorities fail to comply and never provide fair compensation. 2. No tribal participation in the developmental process. 3. No tribal voices are heard when not even basic minimum facilities are available. 4. Sixth Schedule, PESA implementation: despite the formation of the TAC, there is no meaningful engagement with tribes to understand issues, and no powers to representatives to implement.
Lack of communication between Adivasis and the people formulating the policies: 1. This leads to lacunae in the existing policies leading to exploitation. Eg despite the Gram Sabha, ie tribal people, being given the authority to deal with land acquisition & land alienation, their voices are usually suppressed. 2. The economic & social developmental policies should be in line with the people's customary laws. Eg introducing modern medicine without consulting tribals would lead to failure of the plans.
The solutions to this lack of communication: 1. NGOs & voluntary organisations can act as vehicles to carry information & grievances of people to the government. Eg tribal health assemblies held by the Search NGO of Gadchiroli identify the health problems and convey them to higher authorities for developing health plans for tribals. 2. The Tribal Advisory Council should also have broader powers to discuss issues related to tribal people.
Thus, strengthening the participatory democratic approach in tribal areas is the surest way to their development.