5.c) Pseudo-tribalism
Rajput Neha Uddhavsingh, AIR 51, 2023
Pseudo-tribalism is a term used to describe the process of ascribing the status of tribals in a false manner, even when they aren't really tribals.
Causes of pseudo-tribalism: 1. Lower castes: the SCs have borne the brunt of lower status for years and thus, to escape this, try to attain the scheduled tribe status (no hierarchy). 2. Benefits of tribal rights: anyone who wants to extract resources from forest can get easy access if they already have the status of scheduled tribes. 3. Socio-economic benefits: the Constitution under Article 15(4), 16(4) provides educational & employment reservation & opportunities for scheduled tribes. Thus, to avail these benefits, even higher caste people might try to get scheduled tribal status.
Loopholes in the system: 1. Similarly named tribes might be awarded the ST status, eg Goundas are SC whereas Gounds are tribals. 2. [?]fication of certificates. 3. There is no uniformity in the tribal (ST) status, eg the tribe X might be ST in one state & SC in another.