Write a note of 150 words on the following: (a) Ghurey-Elwin debate on tribe
Rajput Neha Uddhavsingh, AIR 51, 2023
Ghurye & Elwin are both among the most respected anthropologists. However their take on the tribal people and the plan for their development is in contradiction to each other & hence the debate.
Elwin's take on tribals: 1. Verrier Elwin was appointed as the tribal advisor to the government during the British era.
Policy of Isolation: 1. He thought tribals were 'Noble Savages'. 2. They must be isolated from the mainstream completely & given their autonomy. 3. National Forest theory -> to protect tribals.
Ghurye's take on tribals: Ghurye was of the view that tribals are backward Hindus. It is that they are the lowest in the hierarchy and have been imitating the non-tribals.
Policy of Assimilation: Ghurye suggested that tribals should be completely & wholly assimilated into the national mainstream and they should be adopting all mainstream culture, dropping all their tribal customs.
Despite such polar opposite opinions, India after independence chose the Madhyamarg of Tribal Panchsheel.