Topper Copies

2.b) One of the main factors behind poor tribal condition is failure of tribal representatives in India's political structure to raise their voices.

Rajput Neha Uddhavsingh, AIR 51, 2023

The tribal people constitute almost 8.6% of the population. However, some of the indicators show the poor tribal conditions still prevailing despite many efforts.

Poor tribal conditions: 1. Indebtedness: the Household Survey of India's citizens has shown that every 2 out of 3 poor persons have informal loans (tribals under the clutches of moneylenders). 2. Land alienation: 47% of STs have faced displacement due to development. 3. Health poor, mortality rates are double the average. 4. Educational: literacy rate is 59% as compared to 72% of the national average.

Failure of tribal representatives to raise their voices: 1. PESA, 1996: this Act extends the Panchayat system to the scheduled areas. - Criticism: despite the Gram Sabha having tribal representatives, their voices against land alienation go unheard; many a times no permission is taken & these are sometimes dominated by non-tribals too. 2. The Tribal Advisory Council: consists of 3/4th members in legislative assemblies. - Limitations: 1. TAC has very minimal rights to discuss issues. Issues only referred by government can be discussed. 2. The referral goes to the Governor, who may or may not take any action. 3. Asia's Indigenous & Tribal People report states that their meetings are tokenistic and no real power is present. 4. The constitution provides Article 330 & 332 for reservation of tribals/STs in the state assembly & parliament, however most of the times they fail to bring any reforms.

Way forward: the Xaxa Committee has recommended restructuring & restrengthening the political structures and betterment of their implementation, eg the TAC needs to be given broader issues and not just an advisory role but also powers to implement.