Topper Copies

Q2. (a) Discuss United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples. To what extent they are being followed in India?

Rajput Neha Uddhavsingh, AIR 51, 2023

The United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous People describes the definition of the 'indigenous people' and adopts the idiom of 'Rights & Empowerment of Indigenous people' as prescribed by the ILO Convention 169.

Indigenous people are identified through this criteria: 1. Historical continuity of their existence pre-colonial times 2. Distinct language, culture 3. Non-dominant community 4. Distinct social & economic & political organisation

The indigenous people are: 1. Entitled to forest & land rights 2. Entitled to preserve their cultural identity and customs

India hasn't ratified the ILO Convention 169 that describes the rights and empowerment of tribes because of two reasons: 1. It threatens our national integrity & unity 2. Tribals would then be labelled as indigenous people

Anthropological debate about whether the Indian tribal people are indigenous or not has been going on for decades.

Some arguments in favour: - Marginalized section - Extremely exploited due to colonisation - Even if not original settlers, time is very long of settlement - They consider their land as sacred & not some legal entity

Arguments against: 1. Multiple invasions & conquests. Thus many different cultures & languages have been a part of India. So what reference point for indigenous people. 2. Tribal & non-tribal have coexisted peacefully & been in contact for centuries. Acculturation has taken place. 3. According to K.S. Singh, People of India Survey says that almost 67% of tribes have migrated from their original habitat.

Despite this, even though officially we have not labelled them as indigenous people, certain safeguards of their rights have been given in India.

Constitutional rights: Article 15, 15(14), 16(4), 23, 29, 46. They prevent discrimination, against bonded labour, protecting their cultural diversity.

Legal provisions: 1. Forest Rights Act, 2006 - Individual ownership: 4 hectares - Community ownership: MFP, grazing etc. - Managing forest rights - Gram Sabha to decide land allotment & prevent land alienation 2. Land Acquisition Act, 2013 - Provides 2-4 times compensation - Social Impact Assessment - Rehabilitation provisions 3. Resettlement & Rehabilitation Policy, 2007 - Provides land for land - Job opportunity - Skill development

Despite many provisions, due to lack of political will & commitment & apathy towards tribal people, the implementation of these rights has been hampered.