Que.6 (b) क्या आप सहमत हैं कि क्रियात्मकता (Functionalism) का सिद्धांत विरोधाभासी एवं अस्पष्ट है? (15 अंक) Do you agree that the theory of functionalism is contradictory and vague?
Animesh Jain, AIR 63, 2025
Functionalism is a liberal alternative to realism. Functionalism emphasise on cooperation in technical areas or areas of low politics like health, disaster, education, trade etc.
They believe cooperation in one area will result in spillover effects in area of high politics leading to increase in trust among nations.
scholars like (David Mitrany) calls for peace by pieces -> cooperate in technical areas thereby removing mistrust. They calls for engagement of civil society, scientists, academicians, people to people exchange to build trust.
In words of Richard Cobden - 'keep the politicians out'.
Theory of functionalism was in play in India's, '2+6' agreement with Pakistan and its dealings with China where it kept aside boundary dispute and cooperated in other areas.
However, functionalism is criticised as contradictory & vague by Realist scholars. On one hand functionalist call for 'keeping politicians out' but politicians are needed to facilitate cooperation in technical areas.
Realist also criticise functionalist for undermining state, power seeking behaviour in states & for 'relative gain' and not absolute gain. This compromises state's trust in mutually beneficial partnerships.
In response, emerged neo-functionalism.. Thus they argue, politicians have to be called back. They emphasise on need for formal institution to facilitate cooperation in low-politics area. For example, European Union & ASEAN can be seen as a successful model of functionalism.
Thus, functionalism remains most liberal practical alternative to realism.